Used Tesla for Sale in Indianapolis, IN

Searching for a used Tesla near Indianapolis?

Tesla is an American electric vehicle company that can boast of producing the Tesla Model 3, the best-selling car for the month of September 2021, with over 24,500 registrations and a 2.6% market share. With the largest selection of used cars for sale, Indy Auto Man can help find the perfect Tesla for you.

Test drive used Tesla cars and SUVs at home in Indianapolis, IN. Browse 9 used Tesla cars for sale, including a 2018 and 2019 Tesla Model 3 Long Range, a 2020 Tesla Model 3 Performance, a 2014 Tesla Model S, a 2014 Tesla Model S P85D, a 2020 Tesla Model Y Long Range, a 2016 Tesla Model X 90D, and a 2017 Tesla Model X 75D, ranging in price from $39,000 to $75,000.

Find great deals on pre-owned Teslas near you. Browse our used Tesla for sale in Indianapolis, IN listings to find the best deals on Tesla in Indianapolis. Research and compare prices on Model 3 and Model S, Model X, and Model Y listings.

An overview of Tesla models for sale near Indianapolis, IN

Here at Indy Auto Man, we’re committed to providing our Indianapolis, Greenwood, and Beech Grove drivers with the ultimate dealership experience. From a comprehensive selection of electric used cars and SUVs, like Tesla, to car loans and friendly service, there are a variety of reasons why our customers continue to return to our conveniently located Indianapolis car dealership. The Indy Auto Man team will provide you with the continued service you need to enjoy every mile. Visit us at 4031 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227 where we’re just a quick drive away from Fishers, Westfield, Plainfield, Noblesville, Whitestown, and beyond. We truly look forward to assisting you today and in the future with all of your automotive needs! Call us at (463) 300-4500.

Silver 2017 Tesla Model X for sale

2017 Tesla Model X 75D


238 miles range*

91 / 95

City / Hwy MPGe rating**

2017 Tesla Model X 75D

Indy Auto Man is proud to offer this wonderful-looking 2017 Tesla Model X in Silver Metallic with Leather Seats, Sunroof, Backup Camera, Navigation System, Bluetooth, 3rd-row seating, heated front seats, USB Port, AUX Input Jack, and Rear View Camera. Model X 75D is electric 4D Sport Utility in Silver Metallic with White w/Leather Seat Trim or Synthetic Leather Seat Trim, 4 cameras, ABS brakes, alloy wheels, compass, Electronic Stability Control, Enhanced Autopilot, Power Liftgate, Front Bucket Seats, Front Center Armrest, Front Dual-Zone A/C, Heated Door Mirrors, Heated Front Seats, Illuminated Entry, Lane Keeping w/Automatic Steering, Low tire pressure warning, Self-Parking, Split-folding rear seat, Traction control, Traffic-Aware Cruise Control.

Blue 2020 Tesla Model Y for sale

2020 Tesla Model Y Long Range


316-mile range*

127 / 114

City / Hwy MPGe rating**

2020 Tesla Model Y Long Range

Indy Auto Man is proud to offer this fantastic-looking 2020 Tesla Model Y in Deep Blue Metallic with Leather Seats, Sunroof, Backup Camera, Navigation System, Bluetooth, Heated front seats, push-button start, USB Port, AUX Input Jack, CARFAX no accidents, Model Y Long Range, 4D Sport Utility, Electric ZEV 241hp, 1-Speed Automatic, AWD, Navigation System.

Priced below KBB Fair Purchase Price! CARFAX One-Owner. Clean CARFAX. The odometer is 12,289 miles below the market average! 127/114 City/Highway MPG

Black 2018 Tesla Model 3 for Sale

2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range


310-mile range*

120 / 112

City / Hwy MPGe rating**

2018 Tesla Model 3 Long Range

Indy Auto Man is proud to offer this wonderful 2018 Tesla Model 3 in Obsidian Black Metallic with Leather Seats, Backup Camera, Navigation System, Bluetooth, and more. Heated front seats, heated steering wheel, push-button start, USB Port, AUX Input Jack, Model 3 Long Range, 4D Sedan, Electric ZEV, 1-Speed Automatic, RWD, Obsidian Black Metallic, ABS brakes, alloy wheels, Compass, Electronic Stability Control, Front Dual Zone A/C, heated door mirrors, Heated Front Bucket Seats, heated front seats, heated rear seats, illuminated entry, low tire pressure warning, navigation system, remote keyless entry, traction control.

2014 Tesla Model S P85D


242-mile range*

86 / 94

City / Hwy MPGe rating*

2014 Tesla Model S P85D

Indy Auto Man is proud to offer this terrific-looking 2014 Tesla Model S in Black with Leather Seats, Bluetooth, Heated Front Seats, push-button start, USB Port, AUX Input Jack, Auto Pilot, Model S P85D, 4D Sedan, Electric ZEV 691hp, 1-Speed Automatic, AWD, Black, Black Leather Seats, Navigation System, and Backup Camera. AM/FM/HD/USB w/17″ Capacitive Touch Screen Radio.

CARFAX One-Owner. The odometer is 12,086 miles below the market average! 86/94 City/Highway MPGe.

Per, the Model Y has an acceptable-to-excellent battery range; sleek styling; impressive performance from all models; lots of cargo space; an available seven-passenger configuration; and is supported by Tesla’s expanding supercharger infrastructure.

Find used Teslas for sale at Indy Auto Man.

Looking for a used Tesla in Indianapolis? Look no further than the pre-owned Tesla Model 3, Model Y, Model X, and Model S for sale at our car dealership! Tesla has an undisputed reputation for pioneering cutting-edge technologies, without any compromise on comfort and convenience. Along with a wide range of technologically advanced interior features, you can also benefit from plenty of standard safety features, so your family can stay secure on the Indianapolis roads. Before stopping by for a test drive, be sure to let us know you are coming by filling out the form below! We are looking forward to helping you find the right Tesla car or SUV for your Indianapolis commute.

Drive Home in a Tesla Today!

When you’re ready to upgrade your Indianapolis commute, get in touch with the team at Indy Auto Man to schedule a test drive at your leisure. We’d also be able to answer any questions you may have about the Tesla cars and SUVs at our Indianapolis car dealership! Get behind the wheel of the right vehicle for the best price today.

Why Use Indy Auto Man?

We’ll help you find great deals among the hundreds of vehicles available at our car dealership, and we’ll provide you with window stickers and CARFAX vehicle history for each one. After all, over 10,000 shoppers used Indy Auto Man to find great deals on used cars and used trucks in their area. And when it’s time to get rid of your old ride, sell your car with ease on Indy Auto Man.

If you only want to see cars within your monthly payment budget use our car payment calculator.

Not convinced if a Tesla is the right fit for you?

That’s okay! We make it easy to shop for your next vehicle by year, body type, mileage, price, and much more. On our car lot, you can find other popular electric vehicles such as the Audi E-Tron, Jaguar I-Pace, Chevrolet Volt, and Ford Mustang MACH-E.

Inquire about Tesla

*Based on 45% highway, 55% city driving, 15,000 annual miles, and current fuel prices. Tank size data is provided by, Inc. The range on a tank and refueling costs assume that 100% of the fuel in the tank will be used before refueling. EPA Fuel Economy: 1 gallon of gasoline=33.7 kWh. The data provided is an estimate only. See for up-to-date information.