Indy Auto Man
Opens today at 9:00 AM

Best Commuter Cars in 2024

best commuter cars in 2024 | Indy Auto Man, Indiana

When people think of the city, they typically imagine traffic jams, narrow roads, and a scarcity of parking spots. If your daily driving requires a more appropriate vehicle, this list of the best commuter cars for sale in Indiana in 2024, collected by IAM dealership professionals, will help you narrow your search. Here are the most suitable models for city trips:

  1. Mini Cooper;
  2. Ford Fiesta;
  3. Volkswagen Golf;
  4. Toyota Prius Hybrid;
  5. Chevrolet Bolt EV;
  6. Honda Fit;
  7. Kia Soul;
  8. Mazda CX-3;
  9. Hyundai Kona;
  10. BMW X1.

Criteria for Choosing a Car for the City

Ponder a handful of factors that will guide you in finding the perfect commuter car.

  • Engine capacity. Small cars with a capacity of 1.6 liters are considered optimal for city driving. They have good fuel economy, especially in start-stop driving mode on streets with traffic lights.
  • Transmission. Most drivers prefer an automatic transmission since constantly changing gears in start-stop mode is inconvenient and tiring.
  • Dimensions. When driving around a city like Indianapolis, a compact model is preferable. At the same time, such cars have small trunks, so if this parameter is vital for you, consider more spacious options.
  • Security systems. A good commuter car must have all passive and active safety systems: emergency braking, ABS, pedestrian detection program, blind spot monitoring, parking assistants, and sign recognition.
  • Comfort. The functionality of the interior is no less important. An advanced climate system, heated and cooled seats, a multi-steering wheel option, and navigation will come in handy.

So, let's discover what models are the leaders in commuting in 2024.

Mini Cooper

mini cooper best commuter car in 2024

Classic Minis dates back to 1959. Back then, there was no talk of traffic as intense as it is now, but manufacturers have already thought about making the car more compact for ease of use in urban environments. In 1994, BMW bought the brand and breathed new life into the Mini Cooper concept. In 2024, the Mini Cooper is equipped with powerful high-tech engines that make driving in a city a real pleasure. Representatives of this brand are common in various ratings and tops of small cars for the city and can be rightfully called one of the best commuter cars.

Ford Fiesta

The Ford Fiesta's engine will allow you to easily keep the pace of big city life. This is a fast and dynamic car for getting to work with a spacious trunk for its size (14.4 cubic feet in a hatchback). The undoubted advantage of the Ford Fiesta commuter vehicle is its reliable chassis, which ensures the long-term operation of the car without failures. Fuel consumption is very economical - equipped with the most powerful engine available, 155 hp requires only 5.5 liters per 60 miles. The Ford Fiesta is also quite affordable, especially considering the high quality and technical specifications.

Volkswagen Golf

used volkswagen golf for sale in Indianapolis dealership

From year to year, the German manufacturer improves one of the most popular models of its cars, and, in 2024, already the eighth generation of the Volkswagen Golf is available to customers. The modern Golf has undergone some changes in design - this is what allows it not to go out of fashion. It continues to be one of the most advanced commuter cars on the market in terms of technical characteristics. Consumers note the high comfort of the cabin for both the driver and passengers.

Toyota Prius Hybrid

Toyota Prius is a highly popular hybrid car that combines efficiency and environmental friendliness. This model is known for its reliability and outstanding fuel economy, making it a great choice for frequent city commuters. The driver's cabin can boast cockpit-style, with intuitive controls and an innovative infotainment system. In addition, the Prius is an exceptional daily traveling vehicle equipped with advanced technologies for safety and convenience, such as an adaptive cruise control, collision warning system, and drive mode selection.

Chevrolet Bolt EV

Chevy Bolt for sale in Indianapolis dealership

The Chevrolet Bolt is an electric car with high energy efficiency and modern design. The advanced battery and EV technology allow this commuter car to travel up to 238 miles on one charge, making it one of the longest-range EVs on the market. The interior design of the Chevrolet Bolt EV also impresses. It is spacious, comfortable, and finished with high-quality materials. A navigation system, multimedia screen, and Bose audio system are just a few of the options that make this car the best for daily commutes.

Honda Fit

The Honda Fit is a dynamic option with low fuel consumption. One of the key advantages of the current generation of Honda Fit is its roomy and spacious interior. Once inside, you will see much more space than it might seem from the outside. This provides passengers with comfort and gives this representative of the Japanese automotive industry a significant advantage over its competitors, giving it a well-deserved place among the best commuter cars in 2024. 

Kia Soul

used Kia Soul for sale in Indianapolis | commuter car from a dealer

The Kia Soul looks stylish and is relatively inexpensive - for this alone, it deserves a place on the list of the best cars for driving to work. However, its main advantage is its spaciousness. Kia Soul is an ideal solution for a large family in a modern city like Indianapolis. What you should pay attention to when purchasing is the tires: it is better to refuse a car with low-profile tires, giving preference to more reliable options. This recommendation is especially relevant for cities with not-highest-quality road surfaces.

Mazda CX-3

Japanese reliability and quality – this is why the Mazda CX-3 has won the hearts of motorists in Indiana, and the whole US. When it comes to urban settings, its unquestionable advantage is its maneuverability and dynamism, paired with a high level of control and a responsive braking system that enhances safety and enables quick reactions to road situations. The technological equipment of the Mazda CX-3 is also at the level: it has cruise and climate control, a navigation system, heated front seats, and various sensors. And this is just the basic package. Low fuel consumption is also an advantage. Among the shortcomings, users note that the trunk volume is not too large.


If your budget is not very restrained, the BMW X1 is an excellent choice for your everyday driving in 2024. The vehicle has undergone a complete redesign for 2023, featuring an upgraded infotainment system and a stronger base engine. The BMW X1 is a compact crossover for active lifestyle. Fast, maneuverable, and stylish, this commuter car will easily blend into heavy traffic and find a place in a crowded parking lot.

Hyundai Kona

The high-tech equipment of the Hyundai Kona allows the car owner to choose a driving mode by environmental conditions and their preferences. This makes commutes to work and back as comfortable and safe as possible. The manufacturer positions the Hyundai Kona as a car for people who prefer an active lifestyle. This is expressed in a powerful and reliable engine and the emphasis on the spaciousness of the interior and trunk.

Selecting a suitable city car is a challenging task, where you need to take into account how often you plan to use it, the number of passengers, and whether you will only travel within the city limits or like to go outside of it for the weekend. Visit the Indy Auto Man dealership, and we will help you make the right choice of your best commuter car. Check our full inventory right now!