105 used sedans, coupes, hatchbacks, wagons, convertibles for sale in Indianapolis, IN

Shop for used vehicles for sale in Indianapolis, Indiana. Large assortment of used sedans, hatchbacks, luxury sports cars, and comfortable wagons from popular brands. Browse pre-owned autos for sale online, and visit the Indy Auto Man car lot in Indianapolis for a test drive. Whether you need a sedan, hatchback, coupe, convertible, or wagon, the best models from our selection of the most popular brands with weekly new arrivals are waiting for you at 4031 South East Street, Indianapolis.

Are new cars or used vehicles better in general?

While new cars attract with first-owner experience, 3- to 5-year-old vehicles are often considered the sweet spot in the Indiana market. In this age range, most cars have already depreciated up to 50% of their initial value while still offering modern safety and comfort features.

When is the best time to buy a car?

You can wait until the discount season and choose from a lower assortment in a crowd of other buyers or benefit from the Indy Auto Man dynamic pricing system, which adapts the car value to hyperlocal market conditions. Visit our website several times a week and see the price changes. Or better yet, submit an inquiry and be notified via email about price change or similar vehicles becoming available. This way, you will define the best time to buy an auto in Indianapolis.

Can you buy an auto with a credit card?

Some lenders in Indiana might allow you to make payments with your credit card, but this is not a common option. As this could be expensive and might negatively impact your credit score. If you opt for a 0% introductory APR credit card, you could pay off your auto loan without accruing interest, but be cautious of high fees and ensure you stay on top of your payments. Using auto credit loans instead is more popular.

Is it better to lease or buy a vehicle?

Both options are worth considering. While buying a car is more expensive initially, it offers complete ownership, unlimited mileage, and lower costs in the long run; leasing prioritizes flexibility with lower monthly payments, warranty coverage, and the possibility to change a car every few years. Check our auto leasing guide to make an informed decision. 

Auto leasing guide

How much is a car registration?

The cost of a car registration in Indiana varies depending on the type of auto you buy. In winter 2025, registering a passenger motor vehicle costs $21.35. You can check the actual full chart on the Indiana State Government website. 

How to register an auto in Indiana

Shop used cars for sale near you in Indiana

At Indy Auto Man, we have a large selection of used cars for you. When you buy a car from us, you get a free Carfax report and a 30-day price match guarantee. We also help with paperwork and have financial experts ready to assist you. Come to choose, compare and test drive a used vehicle today with confidence and ease!