Indy Auto Man
Closed. Opens Monday at 9:00 AM

Best Used SUVs for Sale in Indianapolis

what are the best used suvs | buy used SUVs in Indianapolis
2018 Nissan Rogue SL

Best Used SUVs: Top-Rated Models for Sale in Indianapolis

SUVs are great for both urban drives and trips out of Indianapolis. They are spacious, comfortable, and reliable. At Indy Auto Man, you can select your best used SUV from multiple brands and models gathered at one car lot in Indianapolis. Browse our inventory online right now!

Which SUV to Buy in Indianapolis?

To choose the best SUV in Indianapolis, decide on your own needs and preferences. Used cars of this type can be divided into three groups. SUVs of each category have some special features:

  • Compact SUV. This is the best option for the city, allowing you to easily change the size of the cargo compartement if you require more space for passengers. Compact SUVs differ from similar large-sized cars in their economical fuel consumption, and from sedans in their high cross-country ability and four-wheel drive . But at the same time, mini-SUVs are of little use for real off-road. The best compact SUVs for sale in Indianapolis are Toyota RAV4 , BMW X3 , Honda CR-V (and its “younger sister” – the updated HR-V ).
  • Medium-size SUV . In terms of value for money, the best SUVs belong to this group. In addition, these cars are considered the most versatile. On the one hand, they, like large SUVs, are equipped with spacious seats and provide a high driving position, and on the other hand, they differ in more economical fuel consumption. The best mid-size crossovers are capable of off-road handling. This group includes Mercedes GLC , Lexus RX , Toyota 4Runner .
  • Full-size SUV . The passenger load of such a car can reach 8-9 people, but the fuel efficiency is low even in the best models. The advantages of such vehicles also include excellent interior characteristics and the ability to overcome the most severe off-road conditions. At the same time, the price range in this category is the widest. This group of SUVs includes Chevrolet Tahoe , GMC Yukon , Audi Q7 , Land Rover Discovery .

Read further to find out more about the best SUVs to buy used in Indianapolis.

Lexus RX 350 – The Most Reliable Older SUV

buy used Lexus RX 350 in Indianapolis
2019 Lexus RX 350

Lexus RX-350 has a luxurious sporty design. In the fourth generation, after restyling, the exterior has become even more aggressive.


  • powerful engine 3.5 l, 277-295 hp;
  • AWD or FWD;
  • 6 and 8-speed automatic transmission;
  • fuel economy – 23 mpg combined;
  • max speed 155 mph, acceleration to 60 mph in 7.7 seconds;
  • smooth transmission of torque;
  • integration of the stability control system, which minimizes the roll when cornering and in dynamics;
  • ABS, the Traction Control function;
  • 10 airbags.

Overall, the Lexus RX-350 scored 5 out of 5 for safety.

BMW X5 – Best Second Hand SUV to Buy in Indianapolis

buy used BMW Suv in Indianapolis
2018 BMW X5 xDrive35i

The German style is felt in the design and equipment of the BMW X5 SUV – a bit brutal, dynamic, and very practical. At the same time, the X5 was created specifically for sale in North America.


  • Impressive capability – 3 l engine (6 cylinders), from 245 to 381 hp;
  • fuel type – gasoline or diesel, consumption per 60 miles – 6.7 l;
  • gearbox – 8-speed automatic;
  • acceleration to 60 mph in 5.3 seconds;
  • all or rear-wheel drive;
  • four zone climate control;
  • wide electronic functionality;
  • ergonomic functional dashboard.

Nissan Rogue – The Cheapest Most Reliable Used SUV

used Nissan SUV for sale in Indianapolis
2020 Nissan Rogue SV

On the bottom line of our top three in the ranking of the best used SUVs is the Nissan Rogue family SUV. Its main advantages are economical fuel consumption and a good choice of configuration options. Read Rogue vs. Murano comparison .


  • 2.5-liter engine 170 hp;
  • drives on gasoline, consumes 8-12 l / 100 km (highway / city, respectively);
  • has a full or front-wheel drive – all on a CVT gearbox;
  • equipped with high ground clearance, so it will cope with any off-road;
  • very spacious, well-decorated, and comfortable interior.

Honda CR-V – The Best SUV Under $15,000

Honda cr-v buy used in Indianapolis
2017 Honda CR-V Touring

We ranked the Honda CR-V the fourth in our list of the best used SUVs in Indianapolis. US drivers love the СR-V for its compactness and excellent maneuverability in crowded city traffic. The most demanded model years are 2014-2018. But if you want to buy the best SUV for under $15,000, consider the 2013 Honda CR-V.


  • 1.5 – 4 l engine;
  • power 128-192 hp;
  • four-wheel drive, gearbox – variable;
  • fuel economy 8 mpg city and 34 mpg highway with a combined 30 mpg;
  • xenon headlights with LEDs;
  • the roomy interior can comfortably accommodate 5 people.

Mazda CX-5 – The SUV with the Best Fuel Economy

buy used Mazda cx-5 in Indianapolis
2020 Mazda CX-5 Touring

Distinctive features of the Mazda CX-5 are compactness, lightness, efficiency, high engine performance. According to these indicators, the Mazda CX-5 SUV can be confidently called the best in its class.

The car entered the American market in three trim levels: Sport, Touring, and Grand Touring. The basic package included a built-in CD player with iPod / USB, an audio jack, and Bluetooth.


  • engine 2 l, 155 hp;
  • for front-wheel-drive 6-speed manual or automatic, for all-wheel drive – automatic transmission;
  • fuel economy is quite high thanks to the start-stop system – on average 24 mpg in the city and outside the city 30 mpg.

The updated modification used a 2.5-liter engine, 186 hp, with front and all-wheel drives, automatic transmission. Fuel consumption has increased slightly – up to 22 mpg city and 27 highway.

Buy Your Best Used SUV in Indianapolis

If you want to buy the best SUV that will become your reliable associate in everyday drives and long trips, pay attention to the following details:

  • Determine the budget , taking into account the subsequent costs of the car (cost of maintenance, insurance, etc.). Try our convenient car loan calculator .
  • Select a manufacturer. Each car producer has advantages and disadvantages, for example, Volkswagen SUVs have rigid suspension, Hondas have a short body life.
  • Decide on the engine type. Diesel engines are more economical and resistant to moisture, while gasoline ones are better adapted to weather conditions.
  • Fuel Consumption. Economical fuel consumption and an optimal ratio of mass and engine power are important for this class of vehicles. Read about fuel-efficient cars .
  • Clearance. When choosing a used SUV, look for high ground clearance (1-2 inches above the expected obstacles) and sufficient wheel width. This will provide ease of movement over rough terrain, snow, and sand.

Before buying a car, compare the best ones on the road. At Indy Auto Man, you can choose from more than a hundred used SUVs of any size and configuration. Schedule your appointment right now!