Indy Auto Man
Indy Auto Man
Closed. Opens Monday at 9:00 AM
Closed. Opens Monday at 9:00 AM

Avoid Buying These 6 New Cars in 2024

new car models to avoid in 2024

With today’s high interest rates and inflated MSRPs, buying a new car, truck, or SUV is not a decision to take lightly. In a challenging market like this one, it’s all about getting as much bang for your thinly stretched buck as possible. That said, some new models should give drivers pause, no matter how tempting the loan offer might be. Here’s a look at the new cars that don’t stack up to the competition in their segments in 2024.


Mitsubishi Mirage

With a starting price under $18,000, drivers on a budget might be tempted to settle for the Mitsubishi Mirage — especially since it’s a subcompact hatchback, an extinct species on the market. But buyers should know that it’s not inexpensive. It’s cheap. “Owners complain about the lack of power and claim the car is not fun to drive,” said Melanie Musson with AutoInsurance.org. With a comically inadequate three-cylinder, 78-horsepower engine, the Mirage is a glorified golf cart with barely enough muscle for quick jaunts around town, much less highway driving. “There haven’t been enough updates to indicate that the 2024 model year will be any better,” Musson said. “So if you care about performance, you should look into a car with more oomph.” 

Range Rover — And Most of the Land Rover Lineup

Joe Giranda, director of sales and marketing for international auto shipping firm CFR Classic, cites the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study in calling “Land Rover the least reliable car brand on the market.” Land Rover exceeded the industry average of 186 problems per 100 (PP100) vehicles with an ugly 273 PP100 vehicles in 2023. “Echoing similar results, Warrantywise placed a Land Rover model on the bottom of their list,” Giranda said. “The report gave the Range Rover a 20.2/100 score, citing very frequent electrical and mechanical repair issues that largely affected how reliable the vehicle was. On average, owners are predicted to have dealt with at least two repair issues in a year.” 

Nissan Armada

The largest vehicle in the Nissan lineup, the Armada boasts a powerful standard V8 engine — but its primary selling point is also one of its biggest drawbacks. “The 2023 Nissan Armada is not fuel efficient,” said Talha Atta, mechanical engineer and editor of Auto Globes. “Also, the Armada’s maneuverability may be hindered, especially in tight spaces or urban environments, due to its substantial size and weight. Navigating through congested areas poses a challenge. Lastly, despite Nissan’s gradual improvement in reliability, some consumers may need to be more concerned about forthcoming maintenance costs.” MotorTrend rates the Armada’s five-year ownership costs as “poor” across all four trim options and pans its third row as “cramped.” 

Jeep Wrangler

The Wrangler is undoubtedly an icon, but off-road warriors might want to look elsewhere. “The 2023 Jeep Wrangler is, without a doubt, the worst vehicle that consumers should avoid buying,” said Robert Luterzo, automotive engineer and editor of Automotive Widget. Luterzo cited the Wrangler’s subpar fuel efficiency, but mostly he was leery of its reliability. “Throughout 2023, including the previous year, the Jeep Wrangler has encountered a range of issues, including reports of a faulty electrical system, troubled engine performance, problematic powertrain behavior, concerns related to steering performance, structural integrity worries, compromised visibility aspects and instances of lane departure difficulties,” Luterzo said. “Similarly, engine troubles could result from quality control lapses during manufacturing, impacting the engine’s performance, fuel efficiency, and overall dependability.” 

Nissan Sentra

If you’re in the market for one of the dwindling number of sedans, you might have read that Nissan recently recalled more than a quarter-million Sentras for issues that can cause a loss of steering control. This came as no surprise to at least one expert. “The Nissan Sentra is a well-known name in the world of affordable sedans for its reputation for excellent gas mileage,” said Azzam Sheikh of Carifex. “On the other hand, it has a reputation for being one of the least reliable vehicles available today. The engine, the transmission, and the electrical systems are the most common places for faults to manifest.”

Volkswagen Atlas Cross Sport

Although none of the experts who spoke with GOBankingRates mentioned the 2023 VW Atlas Cross Sport, it has earned an unenviable place on this list. According to Consumer Reports, it has the lowest consumer satisfaction rating of any car on the road — just 38% of owners would buy it again. J.D. Power gives it just 72 out of 100 in terms of reliability and Car and Driver cautions drivers about its “mediocre interior materials, substandard fuel economy,” and an available V6 that underperforms.

If you want to buy a reliable vehicle for years to come that won’t make a hole in your budget, check the IAM inventory of the best used cars for sale in Indianapolis. With crystal-clear history and scrupulous inspections behind it, each car comes with 7-day exchange and 30-day price match guarantees. Choose your favorite model and schedule a test drive!