Indy Auto Man
Indy Auto Man
Open today 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
Open today from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM

Affordable Dream: Used Cars Under 10 000 Dollars in Indianapolis

used cars under 10 000 | Indianapolis, IN
2008 BMW 1 Series 135i

Affordable Dream: Used Cars Under 10 000 Dollars in Indianapolis

A limited budget is not a reason to refuse your dream of buying a car. At Indy Auto Man, Indianapolis, for $10,000 or less, you can find a quality used vehicle that will serve you well for dozens of thousands of miles. Whether you need a small city car or a reliable truck for hard work, you will always find several options to meet your needs among 300+ items available for sale. Check the assortment right now!

What Car Can I Get with $10,000?

If you want to buy a used car for under $10,000 in Indianapolis, you will be surprised by the diversity of brands and models available in this price range. Ten thousand dollars is not the widest, but a realistic budget for buying a used mid-range car at Indy Auto Man.

Get much more options – consider transforming your budget into a car loan down payment and unlock all the benefits of used car financing in Indianapolis even if you don’t have a perfect credit history .

What Is a Good Car but Cheap to Buy in Indianapolis?

cheap but reliable used cars to buy in indianapolis
2011 Buick Regal CXL RL2

The Indianapolis used car market can generously offer plenty of good cars, even if you have a restrained budget. But if you consider vehicles under $10,000, you should expect their average age to be around ten years, depending on the brand, model, and body type.

The main positive moment of such a purchase is the build quality. 10 years ago, the auto manufacturers represented their vehicles with the utmost practicality of inner components and were targeted at the best materials. Later on, the strategy changed to less expensive components. The most popular options in this price range are as follows:

  • Ford Fiesta
  • Fiat 500L
  • Mazda 3
  • Toyota Yaris
  • Honda FIT
  • Ford Focus
  • Dodge Dart
  • Volkswagen Jetta
  • Buick Regal
  • Chevrolet Trax

Let’s consider the Top 3 models from our list in more detail.

Ford Fiesta

used ford fiesta Indianapolis

The Ford Fiesta is an attractive car perfectly suited to the dynamic Indianapolis life. Along with a stylish appearance, the Fiesta boasts an excellent interior. The creators always equip the model with all the advanced technologies available to the date of release.

A well-driving Ford Fiesta has a 1.4-liter engine and an automatic transmission. The negative point of the model is the suspension stiffness and its noise, as well as the high fuel consumption for such an engine.

The Ford Fiesta is a great mid-range car that every Ford fan will love.

Fiat 500L

2019 fiat 500 l

Fiat 500L is a front-wheel drive hatchback. The main difference between this model and its predecessors in the model line is that the car has not three but five doors. The car has increased dimensions, which is why it bears little resemblance to the classic model.

The cargo capabilities of the Fiat 500L are increased markedly, and the list of standard and optional equipment is significantly expanded. The car can be equipped with automatic climate control, a VDC dynamic control system, a glass panoramic sunroof, powerful audio system. In total, about 1500 interior finishes are available in the used car market.

Passengers will like the high ceiling, comfortable seats, and plenty of pockets and compartments. The triangular glass inserts between the windows of the front doors and a large windshield immediately attract attention, as well as headlights of unusual size.

The Fiat 500L models may have diesel and gasoline engines. The trunk of the Fiat 500L can hold up to 400 liters. This model is easy to maneuver and drive around Indianapolis, high seating position and excellent side windows provide excellent visibility. The car will be a perfect choice for lovers of comfort and style for less than $10,000.

Mazda 3

buy used mazda 3 in indianapolis

Mazda 3 is a 5-door front-wheel drive hatchback. The car combines all the advantages of the Mazda models. The appearance of the Mazda 3 testifies to modernity, vigor, and sportiness.

The interior design leaves a lasting impression. The control panel is user-friendly and perfect. Comfortable fit, seat adjustment in 7 modes allows the driver and passengers to sit with maximum comfort. One of the main advantages of the Mazda 3 is its spaciousness. Along with a roomy interior, the hatchback received a trunk with a volume of 350 liters, capable of accommodating bulky cargo.

Equipped with a rich set of active and passive safety equipment, passengers can feel calm and safe. The car is available with 16-inch steel and 18-inch alloy wheels. A 1.6-liter gasoline engine is installed under the hood, developing 120 hp.

Mazda 3 is an excellent city car for Indianapolis, characterized by modern design, dynamism, a high level of comfort, and safety.

What Cars Are the Cheapest and Most Reliable?

Every car enthusiast knows that owning a car entails expenses in addition to the desired status and comfort. An important factor when choosing a vehicle in Indianapolis is the future maintenance costs, especially if its immediate price is under 10 thousand dollars.

Fuel costs

Fuel cost is a daily expense in the operation of the car. The technical specifications will help find out how economical your future vehicle is.

You can easily calculate fuel expenses based on your driving style and average daily mileage. At the same time, remember that the manufacturer data does not consider possible overloads and additional equipment. Therefore, contact the Indy Auto Man sales department to get more accurate figures about the model you want.


Maintenance is an equally significant cost item. But even the approximate cost of work and consumables is not easy to calculate. It all depends on the technical condition of a used vehicle. If you buy a car at a reputed Indianapolis dealership, like Indy Auto Man, you will get a free CARFAX report .

The frequency of maintenance is usually indicated in the service book, which means you can always calculate its cost.

Repair and Spare Parts

Possible repairs can also be ruinous for your budget. Knowing where your car was made will help protect you from unnecessary expenses. The spare parts will cost much less if the manufacturer is located in the US. The repair cost will depend on how complex the design of your car is and whether additional equipment is installed. Contact our Indianapolis service station to find out the cost of spare parts and repairs for your model. Keep in mind, that the older the vehicle, the higher the chances that it requires an expensive service. So, keep the reserve amount for such cases in your pocket.

In most cases, investing in a newer car turns out more beneficial in the long run. Check what options you will have if you raise the budget a bit.