Lexus vs. Mercedes-Benz: Comparing Luxury Brands

Table of Contents

Why choose Mercedes-Benz?
Why choose Lexus?
Disadvantages of Mercedes-Benz
Disadvantages of Lexus
Mercedes-Benz GLS vs. Lexus LX: Compare competitive models
How much do used Mercedes-Benz and Lexus cars lose in price?
How does fuel efficiency vary between used Lexus hybrids and Mercedes-Benz gas models available in Indiana?
Mercedes vs. Lexus: Which used car is better to buy?
Indiana Market Trends

Lexus vs. Mercedes: best used luxury autos in Indiana

When it comes to luxury vehicles in the Indiana market, two names stand out: Mercedes-Benz and Lexus. If you are considering these two brands as the top option for your next used luxury vehicle purchase, check this Lexus vs. Mercedes comparison to understand the strengths and weaknesses of these German and Japanese car manufacturers.

Why choose Mercedes-Benz?

Mercedes-Benz needs no introduction. It was Karl Benz who stood at the origins of the automobile industry. Mercedes confidently leads in the segment of passenger cars and in motorsports to this day. Sedans, hatchbacks, and SUVs with a star on the hood became a symbol of the 90s of the twentieth century. These models are highly valued today in the US and in stable demand on the Indiana secondary market. Often, they are purchased not because of technical characteristics, comfort level, or safety, but precisely because of their prestigious status.

Mercedes vs. BMW vs. Audi

Let's consider some of the advantages of Mercedes-Benz models:

Advanced equipment. Many systems that are on board any car today debuted on Mercedes models.
A wide range of power units. Whether you need an economical diesel car or a high-performance gasoline one, you can choose a specific model of the desired configuration.
High level of safety. Even the cheapest models are equipped with passive and active protection systems that help avoid injuries in accidents.
Status. Cars do not lose it, even despite their considerable age and high mileage.
Availability of charged versions. Almost all models have a civilian configuration and a version from the AMG sports wing.

Why choose Lexus?

The division of Toyota focused on luxury car production has officially offered its product line for quite a long time. Lexus models are valued in the US for their combination of high-level equipment and the reliability of the installed systems. If we compare the resources of the main units, then in this regard, Japanese cars can give odds to any representative of the Big German Three.

Lexus vs. Mercedes-Benz vs. BMW

Lexus vs. Infiniti vs. Acura

Some advantages of Lexus cars:

Reliability. Many Lexus models can travel hundreds of thousands of miles without serious breakdowns.
High liquidity in the secondary market. Such cars find a new owner quite quickly.
A large selection of models. You can buy both a full-fledged SUV and a sports car from the Japanese concern.
Safety. Even models that have not been produced for a long time have the necessary systems on board.
Slow decrease in cost. Lexus is one of the few premium brands that can boast of this.

Disadvantages of Mercedes-Benz

Models of the German company are equipped with a large number of electronic systems. They help the driver in difficult situations and ensure safety. However, failures can occur, which can limit the car's functionality or even interfere with driving. The older the model, the more often you can encounter such problems. This is especially true for the flagship S-class. These problems are well known, so such cars quickly lose value and have relatively low liquidity on the secondary market.

Disadvantages of Lexus

The high level of reliability of Lexus models is well-known. The use of Toyota technologies allows not only to reduce production costs but also to achieve long-term trouble-free operation of units and components. However, at the same time, these cars are quite demanding in terms of service quality. The cost of original consumables and spare parts is quite high, and cheap analogs will quickly lead to problems. In addition, it is no secret that car thieves are interested in premium Japanese models. In this regard, special attention should be paid to the proper and timely auto insurance.

Mercedes-Benz GLS vs. Lexus LX: Compare competitive models

Mercedes-Benz GLS vs. Lexus LX comparison

Mercedes-Benz GLS450 is equipped with a 3-liter turbocharged inline-six engine, which produces an output of 375 horsepower. A 9-range branded automatic transmission is installed in a pair with it without an alternative. The transmission is all-wheel drive. The SUV accelerates to sixty in 5.8 seconds. Fuel economy in the combined cycle is 16 MPG. The model offers a leather interior, numerous electric adjustments, 2-zone climate control, cruise control, LED optics, a virtual instrument panel, and a large monitor (12.3”) multimedia, as well as air suspension.

The Lexus LX is equipped with a 3.4 twin-turbo V6. The engine produces 409 horsepower and 479 lb-ft of torque, and accelerates the car to sixty miles per hour in 6.4 seconds. The 2024 Lexus LX600 has an EPA-estimated fuel economy of 19 MPG combined. Only a standard full-time four-wheel drive is offered. The seats are trimmed with leather and have numerous electric adjustments. Also available is 4-zone climate control, cruise control, a 12.3 ”multimedia monitor with navigation, LED optics, and an air ionization system.

How much do used Mercedes-Benz and Lexus cars lose in price?

Premium segment models depreciate quite quickly. This problem is also typical for Mercedes-Benz. Of course, this primarily applies to S-class models. Usually, such cars are purchased new and then sold when a restyling or the next generation appears. Since the cost of ownership of such models is very high, they have low liquidity. However, this quality makes them an advantageous purchase in the secondary market for any Indiana buyer.

Although Lexus cars are also directly related to the premium segment, their price decrease is much slower compared to representatives of European brands. First of all, due to the well-known reliability of these models. Their liquidity on the secondary market is very high - even cars of a respectable age and with serious mileage are in demand. Experienced drivers understand that if a Lexus is properly looked after, its safety margin will last for a very long time.

How does fuel efficiency vary between used Lexus hybrids and Mercedes-Benz gas models available in Indiana?

Lexus dominates with hybrid options providing excellent fuel savings with models like the UX300h and RX 350h. Mercedes-Benz models tend to focus more on performance, many requiring premium fuel, which may impact fuel budget considerations for Indiana drivers.

Mercedes vs. Lexus: Which used car is better to buy?

Used Mercedes cars can boast an array of configurations, allowing you to find one that fully meets your needs. For example, sophisticated drivers will like the high-performance versions from the AMG division. However, if you do not want to figure out which modification is the most reliable or even just the least problematic, you should consider purchasing a Lexus. These cars offer a comparable level of comfort but demonstrate much more enviable reliability. However, in this case, you will have to put up with the lack of sports versions and more modest dynamics.

Indiana Market Trends

The Indiana used luxury car market in 2025 reflects strong consumer preferences shaped by brand reputation and value propositions. Lexus vehicles, especially hybrids like the RX and UX, enjoy high demand in local dealerships and excellent resale values across Indiana cities including Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, driven by growing interest in reliable, fuel-efficient cars suitable for the region’s mix of urban and rural driving. Meanwhile, Mercedes-Benz remains a favored choice for owners prioritizing prestige and performance, with robust sales of C-Class, GLC, and E-Class models.

Explore the extensive inventory of high-quality used cars at Indy Auto Man, Indianapolis, compare Lexus and Mercedes models, and get approved for a car loan already today!