Table of Contents

Best used sedan models for comfort and value
1. Toyota Camry (2021–2023)
2. Honda Accord (2021–2024)
3. Hyundai Elantra (2022–2024)
Smart SUV choices for Indiana drivers in 2026
1. Toyota RAV4 (2021–2024)
2. Ford Escape (2020–2023)
3. Chevrolet Equinox (2021–2023)
Top used trucks for budget and performance
1. Ford F-150 (2020–2023)
2. Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (2020–2024)
3. Toyota Tacoma (2019–2023)
Best pre-owned hybrid and electric models for sale
1. Toyota Prius (2020–2023)
2. Honda CR-V Hybrid (2021–2024)
3. Tesla Model 3 (2020–2023)
Why 2026 is a great time to buy used models in Indiana
Visit Indy Auto Man: All the best used models for sale near you in Indiana

If you’re shopping for used models for sale in Indiana, now’s your chance to score an amazing deal at the Indy Auto Man dealership, where hundreds of carefully selected vehicles are waiting for their next owner!

Search inventory

After a few unpredictable years in the car market, 2026 is becoming one of the best years for Indiana drivers to buy a used auto. With prices stabilizing and more trade-ins coming in, shoppers can finally find vehicles that hit the sweet spot between quality, features, and price.

Let’s take a closer look at the top used cars of 2026 that deliver the strongest value-to-quality ratio. Our sales analysts at Indy Auto Man created this review to support the savvy buyer's choice, highlighting the models with prominent features and excellent customer feedback.

Best used sedan models for comfort and value

Used sedans pack modern safety features and refined performance while being quite affordable. Here are a few top picks that give Indiana drivers the most value for their money.

1. Toyota Camry (2021–2023)

The Camry continues to top the charts for its reliability and low cost of ownership. Late-model versions, especially from 2022, come loaded with safety tech and Apple CarPlay. With their strong resale value and smooth performance, Camrys are a smart buy at Indy Auto Man’s used car lot.

Toyota Camry vs. Toyota Civic

2. Honda Accord (2021–2024)

With its sleek design, roomy interior, and impressive efficiency, the Accord is perfect for drivers who want an upscale feel without the luxury car price. High-demand trims like the EX-L and Touring often make appearances in Indy Auto Man’s selection.

3. Hyundai Elantra (2022–2024)

Budget-conscious buyers will love the Elantra’s combination of style, fuel economy, and warranty coverage. It’s one of the hidden gems among used models for sale in Indiana, offering great looks and a comfortable ride for less.

Smart SUV choices for Indiana drivers in 2026

Indiana families love SUVs for their all-weather capability and space. And the used market right now is full of strong contenders.

1. Toyota RAV4 (2021–2024)

Few crossover models deliver as much consistent value as the RAV4. Hybrid versions are especially popular for their excellent fuel economy — often over 40 mpg. At Indy Auto Man, you’ll find RAV4s in a variety of trims and configurations to fit different lifestyles.

2. Ford Escape (2020–2023)

The Escape offers a smooth ride, generous cargo room, and available all-wheel drive, making it a strong choice for daily commuters and small families alike. The plug-in hybrid option is also gaining interest among eco-conscious Hoosiers.

3. Chevrolet Equinox (2021–2023)

Built with comfort and dependability in mind, the Equinox is a go-to option for families and first-time SUV buyers. Its low upkeep costs and familiar driving feel make it one of Indiana’s most practical used SUVs.

Chevy Equinox vs. GMC Terrain

Top used trucks for budget and performance

Truck buyers in Indiana in 2026 have a wide choice of capable, affordable used pickups, many with premium features once exclusive to new models.

1. Ford F-150 (2020–2023)

America’s best-selling truck continues to deliver. From fuel-saving EcoBoost engines to powerful V8s, the F-150 can handle just about anything an Indiana workday throws at it. Indy Auto Man frequently carries a range of F-150 configurations for personal and commercial use.

2. Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (2020–2024)

Known for its durability and strong resale value, the Silverado remains a solid pick among used models for sale in Indiana. Mid-level LT and RST trims usually hit the best balance of price, performance, and comfort, making them top sellers in the dealership’s truck lineup.

3. Toyota Tacoma (2019–2023)

A midsize legend, the Tacoma shines for its off-road capability and bulletproof reputation. Perfect for weekend adventurers and city commuters alike, Tacomas in excellent condition are always among the best used models for sale in Indiana.

Toyota Tacoma vs. Nissan Frontier

Best pre-owned hybrid and electric models for sale

Hybrid and electric technology has matured, making late-2020s pre-owned models more affordable and reliable than ever.

1. Toyota Prius (2020–2023)

Still the gold standard for fuel efficiency, the Prius offers unbeatable savings at the pump. The 2023 used models for sale in Indiana can boast modern styling and stronger performance, making the Prius a great mix of function and flair.

2. Honda CR-V Hybrid (2021–2024)

This hybrid SUV provides all the space and comfort of the beloved CR-V with improved fuel economy. It’s dependable, easy to drive, and ideal for both city errands and long road trips.

Best alternatives to the Honda CR-V

3. Tesla Model 3 (2020–2023)

With more EVs entering the used market, Model 3s have become surprisingly affordable. Their tech-forward interiors, impressive range, and quick acceleration make them a standout option for forward-thinking drivers.

Why 2026 is a great time to buy used models in Indiana

A few key market shifts have made this year particularly buyer-friendly:

Slower depreciation: Prices have stabilized, and models just a few years old are holding their value better than ever.
More off-lease returns: A wave of vehicles leased in 2022–2023 is hitting the market, offering nearly new cars with advanced tech and low mileage.
Better reliability and tech: Even base trims from three years ago now include driver-assist systems, hybrid options, and connected infotainment.

All of this means Indiana shoppers can find dependable, feature-rich pre-owned vehicles - a combination that’s hard to beat - at a fair price at Indy Auto Man car lots in Indianapolis and Westfield.

Visit Indy Auto Man: All the best used models for sale near you in Indiana

As 2026 arrives, Indiana’s used car scene is full of opportunity. Whether you need a dependable sedan, a family SUV, or a capable truck, the range of used models for sale in Indiana has never been stronger.

For anyone ready to take the wheel of a quality pre-owned car, Indy Auto Man is the place to start. Stop by the Indianapolis and Westfield car lots or explore our ever-growing online inventory right now!