The Best Crossovers and SUVs of 2026: U.S. Favorites and Indiana Leaders
Table of Contents
- Subaru Crosstrek: Leader among the best crossovers of 2026
- Subaru Forester: Consistently reliable and practical
- Toyota Grand Highlander: Family comfort at its finest
- Lexus NX: The best compact luxury crossover
- BMW X5: Power meets prestige
- Indiana’s Best Crossovers in 2026: Customer Favorites at Indy Auto Man
- Are used crossovers a good investment?
- What mileage is considered good for a used crossover?
- Which crossover offers the best fuel economy?
- Test drive the best crossovers in Indiana
Consumer Reports has unveiled its annual ranking of the best new crossovers and SUVs of 2026. And our pros at Indy Auto Man collected the best of the best to share with our readers. Let’s take a closer look at the models that have earned the trust of American drivers and see how they compare with the Indiana favorites that continue to win the hearts of our customers across Indiana.
Subaru Crosstrek: Leader among the best crossovers of 2026
At the top of this year’s list stands the Subaru Crosstrek, named by experts as the best new SUV of 2026. Its 2.5‑liter flat‑four engine delivers 180 horsepower through a smooth continuously variable transmission, complemented by Subaru’s signature all‑wheel‑drive system.
Analysts highlight its excellent reliability, safety, and everyday versatility - factors that make it a consistent favorite among Indiana drivers seeking all‑season confidence and fuel efficiency.
Subaru Forester: Consistently reliable and practical
The Subaru Forester follows closely behind, using the same proven powertrain as the Crosstrek while maintaining Subaru’s stellar record for reliability. With its roomy cabin, intuitive controls, and strong safety reputation, the Forester appeals to families and commuters all over the U.S.
Owners often praise its commanding visibility and balanced handling - two features that make navigating Indiana roads effortless year‑round.
Toyota Grand Highlander: Family comfort at its finest
Third place goes to the Toyota Grand Highlander, recognized for its comfort, space, and smart hybrid technology. Experts describe it as “a near‑perfect family SUV.” The base trim features a 2.4‑liter turbocharged engine with 265 horsepower, while hybrid versions range from 245 to 362 horsepower, offering impressive performance with improved efficiency.
Drivers appreciate its quiet ride, refined interior, and generous cargo room - ideal for family getaways across the Midwest.
Lexus NX: The best compact luxury crossover
In the premium compact segment, the Lexus NX outshines 22 tested rivals. Its refined hybrid system, based on a 2.5‑liter four‑cylinder engine, produces up to 240 horsepower while maximizing fuel economy.
Owners appreciate its upscale materials, user‑friendly technology, and trademark Lexus refinement, noting that it brings luxury within reach for everyday driving.
BMW X5: Power meets prestige
Completing the national top five is the BMW X5, a standout in the premium SUV category.
The base model’s 3.0‑liter twin‑turbo inline‑six engine generates 375 horsepower, while the plug‑in hybrid adds electric strength for a combined 483 horsepower.
Experts agree this model remains one of the best crossovers ever tested, offering performance, comfort, and driving excitement that explains its lasting appeal.
Indiana’s Best Crossovers in 2026: Customer Favorites at Indy Auto Man
While national rankings showcase the country’s top performers, Indiana drivers often make choices guided by practicality, reliability, and value. In the used car market, every detail matters - from all‑season handling and fuel economy to long‑term ownership costs. Based on current trends and customer preferences, these are the top-selling pre-owned crossovers in Indiana, available now at Indy Auto Man.
- Honda CR‑V. Known for its refined ride quality, spacious cabin, and outstanding fuel efficiency, the CR‑V remains one of the most balanced compact SUVs on the market. Its standard safety features and smooth handling make it ideal for daily drives around Indianapolis or long weekend getaways.
“The CR‑V handles beautifully and fits my family’s lifestyle perfectly. Great fuel economy for daily commutes.” Mark T., Carmel
- Toyota RAV4 Hybrid – Efficient, responsive, and built to last. Combining Toyota’s proven 2.5‑liter hybrid powertrain with advanced all-wheel drive, the RAV4 Hybrid delivers impressive fuel economy without compromising performance. Inside, it offers intuitive tech and a quiet, comfortable cabin designed for active families.
“I save on gas without sacrificing power — one of the smartest purchases I’ve made.” Lisa W., Greenwood
- Subaru Crosstrek – A rugged yet refined choice for Indiana’s changing weather. Equipped with standard all‑wheel drive, generous ground clearance, and excellent visibility, the Crosstrek handles snow, rain, and rough roads with confidence. Inside, it features updated infotainment options and practical cargo versatility.
“Solid, capable, and comfortable - a true all‑season crossover that gives me confidence wherever I go.” Daniel P., Westfield
- Mazda CX‑5. The CX‑5 stands out for its responsive steering, upscale interior materials, and quiet cabin that rivals luxury brands. It’s a favorite among drivers who value design and dynamics.
“Feels more luxurious than its price suggests. Love the smooth drive and sleek interior.” Emily R., Indianapolis
- Chevrolet Equinox. Offering a roomy interior, user-friendly technology, and efficient turbocharged engine options, the Equinox is built to make everyday driving simple and affordable. Families appreciate its reliability and ease of maintenance.
“Spacious, inexpensive to maintain, and dependable - perfect for our growing family.” Nick S., Fishers
Are used crossovers a good investment?
Crossovers tend to retain their value due to high demand and versatile design. Models such as the Honda CR‑V and Toyota RAV4 consistently rank among the highest for resale value in the U.S.
What mileage is considered good for a used crossover?
Most well-maintained crossovers easily exceed 150,000 miles. A vehicle with under 100,000 miles and a clean service record is generally an excellent choice for long-term ownership.
Which crossover offers the best fuel economy?
The Toyota RAV4 Hybrid leads this list with EPA ratings reaching up to 40 MPG combined, while the Honda CR‑V and Subaru Crosstrek also deliver impressive efficiency for their size.
Check also:
Test drive the best crossovers in Indiana
Discover why these vehicles top local and national rankings. Visit Indy Auto Man to test drive the best used crossovers in Indiana and find one that fits your lifestyle and budget.
Whether you’re drawn to the reliability of a Subaru, the hybrid power of a Toyota, or the comfort of a Honda, your perfect crossover is waiting at the Indy Auto Man car lots in Indianapolis and Westfield.
$270/mo
