Used car dealership near Cicero, IN

At Indy Auto Man, we make used car shopping easy and rewarding for Cicero residents, whether you're commuting on SR-19, heading to Morse Reservoir, or just taking daily short trips. We focus on transparency, quality, and convenience. Our showrooms near Cicero offer great pre-owned vehicles for drivers across central Indiana.

A wide selection of cars for Cicero drivers

We're happy to serve you from our closest location in Westfield, IN - just 15 minutes away on US-31 or 146th Street. Test-drive your favorite cars with our friendly team, who are always ready to consult you on model’s features and help with vehicle comparison.

We have over 600 quality used cars built to handle Indiana roads, weather, and daily life. You can count on their reliability, efficiency, and features for years to come.

Our lineup features:

Gas-saving sedans perfect for daily errands and work.
Family-ready SUVs and crossovers for carpools or adventures.
Durable trucks built for towing, jobsites, or rural tasks.
Efficient hybrids, EVs, and green options.
Versatile vans for cargo, passengers, or business use.

Shop the way you want: online or in person

Cicero customers have total flexibility. Browse our full online inventory anytime, and handle financing or trade-ins online.

Enjoy these perks:

Instant car loan pre-approvals.
Custom payment calculators.
Free trade-in quotes by upload.
We offer free delivery within 250 miles of our Indianapolis or Westfield locations, or you can choose easy pickup.

Hassle-free financing and trade-ins

Our team partners with more than 25 top Indiana banks and credit unions to find affordable rates for any credit situation. You can also get pre-approved online before you visit.

We offer fair, market-based trade-in values that go straight toward your purchase, saving you time and money with no pressure to buy anything.

Why Cicero drivers choose Indy Auto Man dealership

We build lasting trust with no-hidden-fees pricing, constantly refreshed stock, thorough inspections, and warranties. Indy Auto Man dealership operates two showrooms in Westfield and Indianapolis, so you have convenient choices close by.

FAQs from Cicero customers

How can I get the fastest deal from Cicero?

Start online to get pre-approved, choose from over 600 cars, and visit our Westfield or Indianapolis car lot for a same-day test drive. Many customers drive home happy the same day!

What's my trade-in worth?

Get a free, data-driven quote in minutes by uploading photos, or bring your vehicle for quick, detailed evaluation.

Can I buy entirely online?

Yes! You can take virtual tours, sign documents online, and get your car delivered to your home. Of course, visiting our lots in the heart of Indiana lets you experience the vehicle in person.

Special offers for families or first-timers?

You can count on us for extended warranties, family delivery, and financing rates designed to help your budget go further.

Visit Indy Auto Man dealer center near you in Indiana . Your ideal used car is waiting!

Find your next used car, truck or SUV at Indy Auto Man - Indianapolis

Indy Auto Man - Indianapolis is Cicero's destination for cars, trucks, and SUVs. We're located at 4031 South East Street, Indianapolis, IN 46227.

Which store are you planning to visit?

Head south on IN-19 S/S Peru St toward W Brinton St
Continue to follow IN-19 S
(1.0 mi)
Turn left onto E 221st St (1.0 mi)
Turn right at the 1st cross street onto Cumberland Rd (2.5 mi)
At the traffic circle, continue straight to stay on Cumberland Rd (0.5 mi)
Turn left onto E 191st St (0.3 mi)
Turn right onto IN-37 S (7.4 mi)
Take the ramp onto I-69 S/IN-37 S (4.7 mi)
Take exit 200 to merge onto I-465 S/I-69 (19.2 mi)
Take exit 2A toward North East St N (0.3 mi)
Merge onto S East St/N U.S. 31
Continue to follow S East St
(0.4 mi)
Turn right
Destination will be on the right
(233 ft)